Roof Replacement vs. Repair: 8 Key Factors to Consider Before You Decide

While roofing can be a very expensive project, it is certainly one of the most crucial elements of any building, whether it is residential or commercial. Since your property is your biggest investment, you’re always concerned about boosting its durability so that it can provide you with long-lasting protection for years to come. This is why whenever you find any damaged or missing shingles or leaks in your attic, the first question that pops into your head is whether you should consider roof replacement or repair. 

8 Points To Help You Choose The Best Roofing Solution For Your Property:

Roof replacement can include removing the old moisture barrier or shingles, or it can involve getting new roof vents, decks, gutters, or soffits. But minor roof damage repair simply means handling any isolated damage. Whether you’re a homeowner or a business proprietor, knowing when to replace a roof vs repair is important. Our team at DVITO ROOFING has compiled the top 8 considerations you should factor in when picking a roofing solution.

Did you discover roof damage in your property? Take a look at these factors before taking action:

a. Age is not just a number for your roof.

All roofs have an expected manufacturer-based and roofing material lifespan, which makes it important for homeowners to consider roof age and replacement timelines. Most roofs can last anywhere from 10-15 years. If your roof is way past its expected lifespan, it doesn’t make sense to spend on repairs because older roofs are more prone to severe damage caused by wear and tear. 

Pro tip: Even if you try to repair some shingles on your aged roof, you still won’t be able to get a color match because old shingles fade over time and don’t retain their original color.

b. Map the Damage Before it’s Too Late:

After a heavy wind or rainstorm, did some water get under your moisture barrier, or did your roof only lose a few shingles? The extent of your damage can help you determine whether you need a roof repair or replacement. For minor storm damage roof repair, you can either DIY or seek a roofer’s help, but for major problems, replacement becomes unavoidable. 

c. Your Roof’s Personality Speaks Volumes:

The roofing material you have can also help you make the right decision for your roof. For instance, a slate roof that can last for 100+ years can be repaired if only minor labor is involved, but structural failure or severe water damage in your property are all signs you need a new roof. This point also signifies the importance of choosing the right roofing material whenever you’re thinking about some new construction. 

d. A Small Leak Can Lead to a Costly Catastrophe.

Sometimes, roof repair is the right answer. Imagine there’s a leak in your roof and you’ve just heard of an incoming major storm; in that case, you won’t have time to schedule a full roof replacement, and the best solution would be to get temporary repairs to avoid further damage. But if you’re thinking of waiting to deal with your roof after the storm season is over and all the damage is done, then you’re setting the stage for extensive replacement bills.  

e. Thinking Ahead for a Roof Retirement:

If you’re thinking about selling your house in a few years, a roof replacement could increase your house’s market value. Similarly, if you plan on staying for more years, a roof upgrade could help boost the longevity of your house’s life and save you from spending money on frequent repairs if the current damage is too extensive. Further, if damage is caused by a covered peril, then you’ll have the added benefit of insurance coverage for roof replacement.

f. A smart choice that doesn’t cost twice:

If your house or building doesn’t already have an energy-efficient roof, you’re in for a costly ride. One of the most cost-effective roofing solutions is replacing your roof with one that is made from energy-efficient material, as it can help you recover some of the installation costs in energy savings. In the current day and age, many options are available for both business proprietors and homeowners in terms of energy-efficient roofs.

Did you know? Solar roofing shingles are the top-most energy-efficient roofing options, as they allow you to get the benefits of both a solar energy system and a new roof! 

g. New over the old:

If you’re trying to choose between re-roofing vs. full roof replacement, you should know that re-roofing means adding a new layer of shingles over the old ones, which is a faster and cheaper method. But it does have certain cons:

  • If you already have two layers of shingles, your building codes would probably not allow a third one due to the added weight. 
  • If you don’t remove the old shingles, you cannot know if there is damage underneath or not.
  • Re-roofing can also reduce the warranty on the new shingles since they usually don’t stick around as long as a full roof replacement. 

h. Hasty decisions cost twice.

Knowing the average cost of roof repair vs replacement costs/expenses can be an important deciding factor for you. While repair may appear less expensive, that’s not always the case. Repair costs can be much greater if they are per square foot. So, another important factor in making a decision is your budget. If your repair costs exceed the replacement costs, it is the right time to consider roof replacement. 

Conclusion:

Whether you’re a business manager or a homeowner, deciding between roof replacement and repair is hard. But suppose you know the key considerations that should be taken into account for this decision. In that case, you can confidently pick the best option for your building’s roof that doesn’t just enhance its durability but also boosts its value.

FAQs:

Why is it important to do a roof inspection before repair or replacement?
Because it can help you determine underlying issues and analyze the extent of damage. 

How to choose a roofing contractor?
Prioritize a good reputation, licensing, and relevant roofing experience.

What is the quality of a good roof?
It should be durable and resistant to harsh weather conditions.

What is the difference between roof restoration and repair?
Roof restoration focuses on renewing the roof’s longevity and functionality, whereas roof repair only targets specific problems.

Is it worth it to repair a roof?
Yes, only if it is just a few years old and requires minor repairs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *